A Resonant Question: Smokie’s Heartfelt Plea for Connection
The mid-1970s was a particularly fertile period for melodic pop-rock, and the British band Smokie were masters of the form. With their distinctive harmonies, catchy hooks, and the unmistakable, slightly raspy lead vocals of Chris Norman, they crafted a string of hits that resonated with audiences across the globe. While they were known for the infectious singalongs that topped charts, they also possessed a knack for more introspective and emotionally resonant ballads. Among these, a song that poses a tender question born of longing and vulnerability is their enduring classic, “What Can I Do.”
Released in 1976 on their third studio album, “Midnight Café,” “What Can I Do” showcased a slightly softer, more contemplative side of Smokie’s sound, yet it still carried the emotional punch that characterized their best work. While the album itself saw success, reaching significant chart positions across Europe (including #14 in Germany), and featuring other popular tracks like “I’ll Meet You at Midnight,” “What Can I Do” became a single that held its own. It achieved a respectable number 17 on the UK Singles Chart and gained widespread airplay, particularly in Europe, further solidifying Smokie’s reputation as consistent hitmakers with a broad appeal. Its success demonstrated that the band could connect with listeners not just through upbeat anthems, but also through more reflective, heartfelt expressions.
For those of us who recall the smooth sounds of 70s pop-rock drifting from the radio, “What Can I Do” evokes an immediate sense of wistful sincerity and a quiet yearning for understanding. It brings to mind moments of personal reflection, perhaps after a disagreement, or in the face of emotional distance. The story behind the song is a testament to the songwriting talent within the band itself. Unlike many of Smokie’s biggest hits, which were penned by the famed songwriting and production duo Nicky Chinn and Mike Chapman, “What Can I Do” was written solely by Alan Silson, the band’s lead guitarist. This allowed for a more personal and introspective lyrical approach, showcasing the depth of the band’s internal creative capabilities. Recorded at Audio International Studios in London, the song’s production, overseen by Chinn and Chapman, ensured its polished sound while retaining its emotional authenticity.
The meaning of “What Can I Do” is a heartfelt plea from someone who is perhaps feeling powerless in a relationship, yearning to bridge a gap or resolve an unspoken tension. The repeated question, “What can I do / If I still love you?”, encapsulates a sense of frustration and desperation when faced with emotional distance or a misunderstanding. It’s a raw confession of enduring affection despite circumstances, and a humble request for guidance on how to make things right. The lyrics speak to the pain of unfulfilled love or a love that is being tested, where the protagonist is willing to do whatever it takes to mend the connection. Chris Norman’s lead vocal, delivered with his characteristic sincerity and a hint of vulnerability, perfectly conveys this emotional dilemma. The band’s signature harmonies provide a gentle, almost soothing backdrop, emphasizing the poignant nature of the question being asked. The melodic guitar lines and understated rhythm section allow the emotional weight of the song to shine through, making it a classic ballad that resonates with genuine feeling.
For older listeners, “What Can I Do” is more than just a pop song; it’s a poignant reminder of the complexities of human relationships and the timeless desire for understanding and reconciliation. It evokes memories of navigating emotional challenges, of grappling with feelings of helplessness, and of the enduring power of love to compel action, even when the path is unclear. It stands as a testament to Smokie’s ability to craft songs that were not only commercially successful but also deeply empathetic, leaving a lasting impression with its tender question that continues to echo in the hearts of those who remember it best.